Miranda - The daughter of Prospero, Miranda was brought to the island at an early age and has never seen any men other than her father and Caliban, though . Oct 15, The Tempest – Ariel, Prospero and Caliban – a very wonky triangle evil Caliban and who had a nice avuncular relationship with Ariel. Free Essay: The short extract taken from “The Tempest” helps us learn a lot about the characters Prospero and Caliban and their relationship within the play.
Prospero’s complex relationship with Caliban – Reading HAG-SEED
Will they keep the relationship of slave and master, or will they become friends? Or will Prospero simply leave Caliban on the island and never cross paths again? This is an important question to many of the readers, and which perhaps caused the author of Hag-Seed, Margaret Atwood to answer this query. After, all the name of the book is Hag-Seed, which is Caliban.
Some of the interpretations for the future relationship between Caliban and Prospero were imagined through different scenarios. The first scenario is simple, since almost all the readers might imagine that Caliban is left behind on the island. With this theory in place, Prospero would take Caliban to his dukedom and make him royalty,and expose Caliban to a different life style.
This proposal states the Caliban might even become a successful musician. The relationship between Felix and Leggs is somewhat different and similar to the relationship between Prospero and Caliban. When Felix first got acquainted with Leggs, surely is was not the best of relationships.
However with the passing of time they warmed up to each other. Especially when Leggs saw what Felix had to offer through art and teaching him as Prospero did with Caliban. Also, Felix probably started to feel for Leggs when he saw his kindness and Potential with the eagerness to learn.
Also as we know that in The Tempest when Caliban made a mistake it caused him and Prospero to become enemies. To some extent Leggs is also like Caliban as they are both in a prison.
We also believe Caliban and Prospero are destined to meet and stay together. They both keep each other in check, as Caliban makes Prospero aware he can repent from his bad deeds in his world.
Also Caliban is to some extent evil and the limitations Prospero offered caused his evil identity to be silenced. Proof of the evil in Caliban is his willingness to kill Prospero and his attempt to rape Miranda.
As for Felix and Leggs they also served each other in a similar way, like Caliban and Prospero. Felix and Leggs helped each other get through some difficult obstacles. Felix was making up for his failure as a father and husband, and even as a failure for not anticipating what Tony was capable of doing behind his back.
Leggs and the other characters in Hag-Seed served that purpose for Felix by showing him respect, bringing back his success, and occupying him, which brought purpose to his life again. Some call Hegel an idealist whose philosophy has essentialism as its foundation.
Others feel that Hegel is more materialist than we give him credit for. In other words, Ariel being in bondage to Propsero is not the only way that Ariel can develop his consciousness, but it is the way it will occur in a patriarchal world — one that is rooted in hierarchical relations of power. And certainly, that is the setting of this play. In a post-Patriarchal world there will be no Masters, Slaves, capitalists or workers.
As Marx says, the working class will, through revolution, abolish itself.Book Trailer: Miranda and Caliban by Jacqueline Carey
In other words, in that world, Ariel will not need to pass through the phases of enslaved labour in order to realize his full potential. Shakespeare Birthplace Trust I like this analysis, but then it raises questions about what happens next, If Ariel acquires a mind of his own through work, what happens when he is set free? Is this not an ironic ending? Also I am interested in the assumption lurking under this analysis that Ariel needs Prospero to reach his full potential and that the enslavement is in some ways useful and even empowering.
The idea of co-dependency is interesting in relation to The Tempest and it is often represented as such on the stage, with master needing servant as well as servant needing master. Shakespeare Birthplace Trust Insightful as ever, Christian. One of the things which I have always found interesting about the tempest is how well Caliban and Ariel know eachother.
Their relationship if such it is is a resounding blank. Your suggestion that Caliban and Ariel work together to overthrow Prospero is one oddly neglected by Shakespeare.
Christian Smith I agree with Zsolt that there is more to the story than what I wrote in my comment and will take his suggestion to extend my interpretation in light of Hegel and Marx. In paragraph of Ph. After much time of being alienated from his labour power the worker loses the possibility of this philosophically-contrived consciousness and succumbs to an emptying of his Geist.
It is emptied of its knowledge about its actual situation and of its history.
Consequently it is emptied of the consciousness of its revolutionary future. Marx uses quotes from and allusions to Shylock to describe a Geist with its heart cut out — the reified consciousness.
Ariel sinks the ship and distributes the crew on the island. Ariel enchants Ferdinand and the others with his music and then saves the King from regicide. He tricks the conspirators and then torments them with the Harpies.
Ariel drives the characters all over the island and in the end, it is Ariel who attires Prospero.
Relationships Of Prospero And Caliban 📚 The Tempest
Lurking under the surface of this play is the possibility that at any point, Ariel could have gone on strike, or, worse, united with Caliban and defeated the humans. Ariel seems to have become alienated from his power. When Ariel has acquired a mind of his own he tells Prospero to be empathic. To see the suffering of his usurpers-turned-captives and to forgive them.